Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) vs HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads

Bulldogology publishes more checkable detail than anyone else here, including a polymer weight and an absorbency figure tied to a specific sheet size, and it is the only pad in this group whose own page confirms adhesive tabs. HoneyCare gets you the same 6 layer, gel core construction across four sizes for less, provided you can live without the tabs and without a published capacity number.

Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in)

Buy it

The only pad here whose maker publishes a polymer weight, a capacity figure and adhesive tabs on the same page.

• The maker states a 6 layer build with 5 g of super absorbent polymer that converts liquid to gel.
• Adhesive tabs on the pad corners are listed as optional, so you can anchor the pad or leave the tabs covered.
• Four sheet sizes are offered on the maker's site: 24 by 24, 24 by 35, 30 by 30 and 30 by 36 inches.

• The stated capacity of up to 7 to 9 or more cups applies to the 24 by 24 inch sheet, and the maker does not publish separate figures for the larger sizes.
• The built-in attractant claim is presented without any evidence, so do not pay a premium for it.
• Odour control is described as blocking and neutralising odours, which is a claim rather than a measured spec.

Check price

HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads

Buy it

Six layers and a gel core in four clearly stated sizes, at the cheapest per-sheet cost in this group.

• The maker lists 6 premium inner layers and a super absorbent gel core, the same basic construction as the premium pick.
• Four sheet sizes are stated outright: 17.5 by 23.5, 22 by 23, 28 by 34 and 30 by 36 inches.
• Bulk counts of 160 to 480 pads bring the per-sheet cost down further than anything else here.

• The current product page does not publish an absorbency figure in cups or millilitres, so you cannot compare capacity directly.
• Adhesive tabs are not listed on the maker's page, so plan on a pad holder if your dog moves the pad.
• Odour eliminating is claimed across the range without supporting data.

Check price

Side by side

The bottom line

Our overall pick is the Bulldogology Premium Pet Training Pads (24 x 24 in) - The only pad here whose maker publishes a polymer weight, a capacity figure and adhesive tabs on the same page. Choose the HoneyCare All-Absorb Dog and Puppy Training Pads instead if high-volume households, whelping boxes and anyone changing pads often enough that per-sheet cost is the deciding factor.

Want the full picture, including the other options we compared and the popular one we'd skip? Read the complete The Best Puppy Pads: 4 Compared (and One to Skip).